Nine Fine Irishmen Review

An Authentic Irish Pub Experience in the Heart of the Strip

Nine Fine Irishmen stands as a remarkable tribute to traditional Irish pub culture, seamlessly transplanted into the vibrant chaos of the Las Vegas Strip. Located within the New York-New York Hotel & Casino, this establishment offers more than just food and drink—it delivers a genuine cultural experience that transports guests straight to the Emerald Isle.

Atmosphere and Ambiance

The moment you step inside, you're greeted by the rich aroma of aged wood and hearty cuisine. The interior was constructed using authentic materials imported from Ireland, including reclaimed wood, stained glass, and antique fixtures that create a cozy, centuries-old pub atmosphere. The space features multiple levels with intimate booths, communal tables, and a stunning outdoor patio overlooking the Strip's energy. Live Irish music fills the air nightly, with talented musicians performing traditional tunes that encourage spontaneous clapping and even the occasional sing-along.

Culinary Experience

The menu celebrates classic Irish comfort food with impressive execution. Start with the Irish Nachos—a clever twist using crispy potato slices instead of tortilla chips, topped with melted cheese, bacon, and green onions. The Shepherd's Pie is a standout, featuring perfectly seasoned ground beef and vegetables under a blanket of creamy mashed potatoes. For something uniquely Irish, try the Bangers and Mash, where quality sausages pair beautifully with rich onion gravy.

While the traditional dishes shine, the kitchen also offers American favorites like burgers and salads for less adventurous diners. Portions are generous—this is not delicate dining, but satisfying, rib-sticking fare perfect after a long day of exploring Vegas.

Bar Program and Whiskey Selection

As expected from an Irish pub, the bar program excels. Guinness pours are perfection—creamy-headed and served at the ideal temperature. The whiskey selection is extensive, featuring over 30 varieties from Ireland alone, plus Scotch and American options. Knowledgeable bartenders can guide you through flights or recommend pairings with your meal. Don't miss their Irish Coffee, properly made with brown sugar, Irish whiskey, and freshly whipped cream.

Service and Hospitality

Service generally matches the warm, welcoming atmosphere. Staff members, many with authentic Irish accents, are attentive and engaging, though during peak hours the enthusiasm can sometimes outpace efficiency. Wait times for food can stretch during dinner rushes, but the lively atmosphere makes delays more tolerable.

Value Considerations

Given its prime Strip location, Nine Fine Irishmen offers reasonable value. Entrées range from $18-32, with quality that justifies the prices. The experience—especially the live music—adds significant value beyond just the food and drink.

Who Should Visit

Couples will appreciate the romantic, dimly-lit corners and live music. Groups of friends can enjoy the communal spirit and extensive drink menu. Families are welcome during daytime hours, though the evening atmosphere becomes more adult-oriented. Business travelers will find it perfect for informal meetings or solo dining at the bar.

Practical Information

Open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM (until midnight on weekends). Reservations are recommended for dinner, though walk-ins are accommodated when possible. The location within New York-New York means easy access from most Strip locations, with self-parking available in the casino garage.