Il Fornaio Review

Authentic Italian Excellence in the Heart of the Strip

Il Fornaio at the New York-New York Hotel & Casino offers a genuine taste of Italy that stands out among Las Vegas' countless dining options. This restaurant brings Northern Italian culinary traditions to life with impressive consistency and charm.

Ambiance and Atmosphere

The restaurant features a warm, rustic design with exposed brick, wooden beams, and an open kitchen that allows guests to watch chefs hand-rolling pasta and baking bread in the traditional forno (oven). The spacious dining room maintains an intimate feel with well-spaced tables, while the outdoor patio offers stunning views of the Strip's energy. The noise level remains conversational despite the casino location, making it suitable for both business meetings and romantic dinners.

Culinary Excellence

Il Fornaio's menu changes monthly to highlight different regions of Italy, ensuring seasonal ingredients and authentic preparations. Their pasta is made fresh daily - the tagliatelle al ragù and lobster ravioli are particular standouts. The wood-fired pizzas feature perfectly charred crusts with quality toppings. Don't miss their signature antipasti misti and the branzino al sale (sea bass baked in salt). The wine list features over 300 Italian selections with knowledgeable sommeliers available for pairing recommendations.

Service and Experience

Service is generally attentive and professional, though can become slightly rushed during peak hours. Staff demonstrate good knowledge of the menu and provide helpful suggestions. The restaurant's commitment to authenticity extends to their service style, which mirrors the warm hospitality found in Italian trattorias.

Value Proposition

While not inexpensive, Il Fornaio delivers fair value considering the quality of ingredients, portion sizes, and prime Strip location. Their weekday lunch specials and Sunday brunch offer particularly good value. The restaurant also offers a frequent diner program that provides additional perks for regular visitors.

Recommendations

For couples: Request a patio table at sunset and try the tasting menu with wine pairings.
For families: The Sunday brunch buffet provides excellent variety and value for all ages.
For business dinners: The private dining rooms offer sophisticated settings for corporate events.
Best times to visit: Weekday lunches or early dinners to avoid crowds.