Treasure Island vs The D Las Vegas: Mid-Strip Resort vs Downtown Value Hotel Showdown

Accommodations & Room Quality

Treasure Island's 2,884 rooms feature a recent refresh with a sophisticated burgundy and gold color scheme. Standard rooms measure 350-500 sq ft with comfortable pillow-top mattresses, 55-inch smart TVs, and marble bathrooms. The D offers 638 rooms with a modern industrial design featuring exposed concrete ceilings and blackout shades. Rooms are slightly smaller at 300-450 sq ft but include 42-inch LCD TVs and surprisingly comfortable beds. Both properties maintain excellent cleanliness standards.

Winner: Treasure Island (superior room size and amenities)

Dining Options

Treasure Island provides diverse dining including Gilley's Saloon for barbecue, The Coffee Shop for 24-hour casual fare, and Pho & Banh Mi for Vietnamese. The D features Andiamo Steakhouse for upscale dining, American Coney Island for Detroit-style comfort food, and D Grill for casual American. Treasure Island has more options while The D focuses on quality over quantity.

Winner: Treasure Island (greater variety)

Casino Experience

Treasure Island's 95,000 sq ft casino offers a balanced mix of 2,200 slots and 60 table games in a well-ventilated space. The D's casino spans 52,000 sq ft with an emphasis on table games (notably popular craps and blackjack areas) and a unique two-level casino layout. The D's casino has more energetic downtown vibes while Treasure Island provides a more relaxed gambling atmosphere.

Winner: The D Las Vegas (superior table game experience and energy)

Amenities & Facilities

Treasure Island features two outdoor pools, a full-service spa, fitness center, and shopping promenade. The D offers a modern fitness center but no pool or spa facilities. This represents the most significant difference between the properties, with Treasure Island providing full resort amenities while The D focuses primarily on gaming and lodging.

Winner: Treasure Island (comprehensive resort amenities)

Location & Accessibility

Treasure Island's Mid-Strip location provides walking access to The Mirage, Venetian, and Fashion Show Mall with monorail access nearby. The D sits in the heart of the Fremont Street Experience with immediate access to all downtown casinos and attractions. Treasure Island offers better Strip access while The D provides superior downtown immersion.

Winner: Split (depends on preferred location)

Value & Pricing

Treasure Island's room rates typically range from $100-250/night plus $45/night resort fee. The D offers rooms from $60-150/night with a $35/night resort fee. The D provides significantly better value for budget-conscious travelers, while Treasure Island's higher price reflects its resort amenities and Strip location.

Winner: The D Las Vegas (superior value proposition)

Target Audience & Atmosphere

Treasure Island attracts mid-range travelers, couples, and those seeking a complete resort experience with balanced energy. The D draws younger crowds, serious gamblers, and visitors seeking the authentic downtown Las Vegas vibe with high-energy surroundings. Treasure Island offers more family-friendly options while The D caters primarily to adults.

Winner: Split (different target markets)