Treasure Island vs Red Rock: Strip Glamour vs Off-Strip Luxury Hotel Comparison

Location & Accessibility

Treasure Island (Score: 9/10) occupies a prime mid-Strip location adjacent to The Venetian and Mirage. Its central position provides walking access to most major Strip attractions, shopping, and dining. The property connects directly to the Fashion Show Mall and offers convenient access to public transportation.

Red Rock (Score: 7/10) is located 10 miles west of the Strip in Summerlin, requiring 15-20 minute drives to main tourist areas. While more isolated from typical tourist activities, it offers proximity to Red Rock Canyon and Summerlin's upscale residential areas.

Winner: Treasure Island for tourists seeking Strip convenience

Room Quality & Amenities

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) features 2,884 rooms recently renovated with modern furnishings. Standard rooms average 450 sq ft with comfortable bedding, 55-inch smart TVs, and marble bathrooms. The property shows some wear in high-traffic areas but maintains decent comfort levels.

Red Rock (Score: 9/10) offers 816 spacious rooms starting at 650 sq ft with premium pillow-top mattresses, 55-inch LCD TVs, and luxurious marble bathrooms with separate soaking tubs. Rooms feature floor-to-ceiling windows with mountain or valley views and higher-end finishes throughout.

Winner: Red Rock for superior room quality and amenities

Dining Options

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) provides 10 dining venues including the popular Gilley's Saloon, Phil's Italian Steak House, and The Coffee Shop. Options range from casual to mid-range fine dining with average Strip pricing. The food court offers quick-service alternatives.

Red Rock (Score: 9/10) features 16 dining establishments including eight restaurants by James Beard Award-winning chefs. Highlights include T-Bones Chophouse, Hearthstone Kitchen, and Lucille's Smokehouse Bar-B-Que. The property offers more diverse and higher-quality culinary experiences.

Winner: Red Rock for culinary excellence and variety

Entertainment & Nightlife

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) offers the free outdoor Sirens of TI show (seasonal), a 95,000 sq ft casino, and proximity to Strip nightlife. The property features multiple bars and lounges including the popular Kahunaville nightclub. Its central location provides easy access to external entertainment options.

Red Rock (Score: 7/10) features a 72-lane bowling alley, 16-screen movie theater, and the Sandbar poolside lounge. While offering quality entertainment options, it lacks the large-scale productions and nightclub scene available on the Strip.

Winner: Treasure Island for traditional Vegas entertainment access

Pool & Recreation

Treasure Island (Score: 6/10) offers a single 7,400 sq ft pool with cabanas and bar service. The pool area is functional but relatively basic compared to larger Strip properties, with limited amenities and often crowded conditions.

Red Rock (Score: 9/10) features a 3-acre pool complex with multiple pools, private cabanas, waterfalls, and a sandy beach entry. The resort also offers a full-service spa, fitness center, and direct access to hiking trails in Red Rock Canyon.

Winner: Red Rock for superior pool facilities and recreational options

Value & Pricing

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) offers rooms starting around $79-$129 weeknights, with resort fees around $45. Dining and entertainment prices are competitive with other mid-tier Strip properties. The location provides excellent value for budget-conscious travelers wanting Strip access.

Red Rock (Score: 6/10) commands premium pricing with rooms starting at $149-$249, plus $45 resort fee. While offering superior amenities, the higher price point and off-Strip location reduce overall value for typical Vegas tourists.

Winner: Treasure Island for better overall value

Service Quality

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) provides competent but sometimes inconsistent service. Check-in efficiency varies based on crowd levels, and staff responsiveness meets expectations for a large Strip property without exceeding them.

Red Rock (Score: 9/10) delivers consistently excellent service with attentive staff, prompt room service, and personalized attention. The higher staff-to-guest ratio results in more responsive and polished service throughout the property.

Winner: Red Rock for superior service quality