Treasure Island vs Gold Coast: A Comprehensive Vegas Hotel Showdown

Location & Accessibility

Treasure Island's Strip location (Score: 9/10) provides unparalleled access to major attractions, with Mirage and Venetian within walking distance. Gold Coast (Score: 7/10) sits west of the Strip near the Convention Center, requiring shuttle or rideshare for Strip access but offering easier parking and less congestion.

Winner: Treasure Island

Room Quality & Amenities

Treasure Island's recently renovated rooms (Score: 8/10) feature modern decor, comfortable bedding, and Strip views in premium categories. Gold Coast (Score: 6/10) offers functional but dated rooms with basic amenities, though they're well-maintained and spacious for the price point.

Winner: Treasure Island

Dining Options

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) features diverse options including Gilley's BBQ, Phil's Italian Steak House, and quick-service outlets. Gold Coast (Score: 7/10) surprises with excellent value dining including Ping Pang Pong Chinese restaurant and a popular buffet, though with fewer upscale choices.

Winner: Treasure Island (by narrow margin)

Entertainment & Nightlife

Treasure Island (Score: 9/10) offers the popular Mystère by Cirque du Soleil, multiple bars, and proximity to Strip nightlife. Gold Coast (Score: 6/10) focuses on casino entertainment with regular promotions and a bowling alley, but lacks major production shows.

Winner: Treasure Island

Casino Experience

Treasure Island's casino (Score: 7/10) offers modern gaming with lower limits than premium Strip properties. Gold Coast (Score: 8/10) features a larger casino floor with better odds, lower minimums, and a more local, relaxed gaming atmosphere.

Winner: Gold Coast

Value & Pricing

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) provides good mid-range value for its Strip location. Gold Coast (Score: 9/10) delivers exceptional value with room rates often 30-40% lower than Strip properties and affordable dining options.

Winner: Gold Coast

Service & Staff

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) provides professional, efficient service typical of MGM properties. Gold Coast (Score: 8/10) offers friendly, personalized service with a more local feel and shorter wait times.

Winner: Tie

Pool & Recreation

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) features a tropical pool complex with cabanas and bar service. Gold Coast (Score: 5/10) has a basic pool area functional for cooling off but lacking resort-style amenities.

Winner: Treasure Island