Treasure Island vs Durango: Las Vegas Hotel & Casino Comparison

Location & Accessibility

Treasure Island (Score: 9/10) sits prominently on the Las Vegas Strip between The Venetian and The Mirage, offering unparalleled walkability to major attractions. The monorail station access and proximity to Convention Center make it ideal for tourists. Durango (Score: 7/10) is located in the rapidly growing Southwest Las Vegas area, approximately 20 minutes from the Strip. While quieter and with ample free parking, it requires transportation to reach major attractions.

Winner: Treasure Island

Room Quality & Amenities

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) features 2,884 rooms with recent renovations offering comfortable but somewhat dated decor. Standard rooms average 450 sq ft with basic amenities. Durango (Score: 9/10) boasts 200 brand-new rooms with modern design, premium bedding, and luxury bathrooms. Rooms average 500+ sq ft with high-end finishes and technology integration.

Winner: Durango

Dining Options

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) offers diverse options including The Coffee Bean, Phil's Italian Steak House, and quick-service cafes. Good variety but lacks signature fine dining. Durango (Score: 8/10) features Nicco's prime steakhouse, multiple casual restaurants, and excellent food court options. More modern culinary concepts but fewer total venues.

Winner: Tie

Entertainment & Casino

Treasure Island (Score: 9/10) features the famous Mystère by Cirque du Soleil, lively casino with 95,000 sq ft of gaming, and regular pool parties. Classic Vegas energy throughout. Durango (Score: 7/10) offers a more intimate casino experience with modern slot selection and sportsbook. Limited entertainment options beyond gaming, focusing on relaxed atmosphere.

Winner: Treasure Island

Value & Pricing

Treasure Island (Score: 6/10) rooms average $150-300/night with resort fees around $45. Strip premium pricing applies to dining and amenities. Durango (Score: 9/10) offers rooms at $100-200/night with lower resort fees. Significantly better value for quality received, with more reasonable pricing across services.

Winner: Durango

Service Quality

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) provides competent but sometimes impersonal service typical of large Strip properties. Efficient check-in but can feel crowded. Durango (Score: 9/10) delivers exceptional personalized service with higher staff-to-guest ratio. Noted for attentive staff and seamless experiences.

Winner: Durango

Pool & Recreation

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) features a large tropical pool complex with cabanas, DJ entertainment, and poolside service. Lively atmosphere but can get crowded. Durango (Score: 8/10) offers a sophisticated pool area with luxurious cabanas and relaxed ambiance. Smaller but more upscale experience.

Winner: Tie