The Cromwell vs Treasure Island: Boutique Luxury vs Family-Friendly Value on the Strip
The Cromwell
Treasure Island Las Vegas Hotel & Casino
Overall Quality & Atmosphere
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) stands as Las Vegas' first standalone boutique hotel, offering an intimate, sophisticated atmosphere with Parisian-inspired decor. The property features 188 rooms with high ceilings, custom furnishings, and marble bathrooms. Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) presents a larger, more conventional casino-hotel experience with pirate-themed decor and 2,884 rooms. While well-maintained, it lacks the boutique sophistication of The Cromwell.
Winner: The Cromwell
Room Quality & Amenities
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) rooms average 360 square feet with 10-foot ceilings, premium linens, and deep soaking tubs. All rooms include smart technology and luxurious bath products. Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) offers larger standard rooms (starting at 495 square feet) with comfortable bedding but more basic amenities. Suite options are more extensive at Treasure Island.
Winner: The Cromwell
Service & Hospitality
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) provides personalized service with a high staff-to-guest ratio, including dedicated concierge and 24-hour in-room dining. Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) offers competent but more standardized hotel service typical of larger properties.
Winner: The Cromwell
Location & Accessibility
The Cromwell (Score: 10/10) occupies prime center-Strip real estate directly across from Caesars Palace and connected to the Linq Promenade. Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) sits on the north end of the Strip, requiring longer walks or transportation to central attractions.
Winner: The Cromwell
Dining Options
The Cromwell (Score: 8/10) features Giada De Laurentiis' restaurant and Bound by Salvatore, offering upscale dining. Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) provides more variety with 10 restaurants including The Coffee Shop, Pho, and Gilley's Saloon.
Winner: Tie
Entertainment & Nightlife
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) boasts Drai's Nightclub and Beachclub, one of Vegas' premier nightlife destinations. Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) offers Mystère by Cirque du Soleil and more family-oriented entertainment options.
Winner: The Cromwell
Value & Pricing
The Cromwell (Score: 6/10) commands premium prices ($250-500/night) reflecting its boutique status. Treasure Island (Score: 9/10) offers excellent value with rooms typically $100-250/night and frequent package deals.
Winner: Treasure Island
Pool Experience
The Cromwell (Score: 8/10) features a sophisticated adults-only rooftop pool with Drai's Beachclub. Treasure Island (Score: 7/10) offers a larger, family-friendly pool complex with waterfalls and cabanas.
Winner: The Cromwell
Casino Experience
The Cromwell (Score: 7/10) offers an intimate, high-energy casino floor with table games and slots. Treasure Island (Score: 8/10) features a larger, more diverse casino with poker room and race/sports book.
Winner: Treasure Island