Planet Hollywood vs Treasure Island: Ultimate Las Vegas Strip Hotel Comparison

Overall Comparison

Both properties offer distinct Las Vegas experiences catering to different traveler preferences. Planet Hollywood excels in contemporary style and premium location, while Treasure Island offers solid value and comfortable accommodations.

Room Quality & Amenities

Planet Hollywood (Score: 8/10): Features Hollywood-themed rooms with modern furnishings, smart TVs, and panoramic Strip views. Rooms average 500-600 sq ft with rainfall showers. Recent renovations maintain contemporary appeal.

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10): Recently renovated rooms offer comfortable bedding and modern bathrooms. Standard rooms are slightly smaller (450-550 sq ft) but well-appointed. Less thematic but practical design.

Winner: Planet Hollywood

Dining Options

Planet Hollywood (Score: 9/10): Exceptional culinary variety including Gordon Ramsay Burger, Strip House steakhouse, and food court options. 24-hour dining at Café Hollywood.

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10): Solid offerings with Gilley's BBQ, The Coffee Shop, and Pho Vietnamese. Fewer celebrity chef options but adequate variety.

Winner: Planet Hollywood

Entertainment & Nightlife

Planet Hollywood (Score: 8/10): Home to Criss Angel Mindfreak show, ultra-lounge, and center-Strip party atmosphere. Direct access to Miracle Mile Shops.

Treasure Island (Score: 6/10): Features Mystère by Cirque du Soleil and more relaxed bar scene. Fewer nightlife options but quality production show.

Winner: Planet Hollywood

Casino Experience

Planet Hollywood (Score: 8/10): 72,000 sq ft casino with modern slot selection and lively table game atmosphere. Younger, energetic crowd.

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10): 95,000 sq ft casino space with comfortable layout and good poker room. Less crowded, more relaxed gaming experience.

Winner: Planet Hollywood

Location & Accessibility

Planet Hollywood (Score: 10/10): Prime center-Strip location connected to Miracle Mile Shops. Walking distance to Bellagio fountains and Cosmopolitan.

Treasure Island (Score: 7/10): North Strip location requires more walking to center attractions. Connected to Fashion Show Mall via pedestrian bridge.

Winner: Planet Hollywood

Value & Pricing

Planet Hollywood (Score: 7/10): Higher room rates ($150-300/night) but premium location justifies cost. Resort fees comparable to Strip average.

Treasure Island (Score: 9/10): Excellent value with rooms typically $100-200/night. Lower resort fees and good package deals available.

Winner: Treasure Island

Pool & Recreation

Planet Hollywood (Score: 8/10): 25,000 sq ft pool complex with cabanas and dayclub atmosphere. Multiple pools and DJ entertainment.

Treasure Island (Score: 6/10): Single pool area with basic amenities. Functional but lacks the resort-style experience.

Winner: Planet Hollywood

Service Quality

Planet Hollywood (Score: 8/10): Generally efficient service with check-in improvements. Concierge and room service meet Strip standards.

Treasure Island (Score: 8/10): Friendly staff with good response times. Smaller property allows for more personalized service.

Winner: Tie