Park MGM vs Treasure Island: Modern Luxury vs Classic Vegas Value

Location Comparison

Park MGM sits at the south end of the Strip, offering excellent access to T-Mobile Arena, New York-New York, and easy monorail connections. Its position provides slightly quicker access to the airport while maintaining walkable distance to central Strip attractions. Treasure Island enjoys a prime mid-Strip location with direct pedestrian bridges to The Venetian and Forum Shops at Caesars, putting you at the heart of the action. Both properties offer strong positioning, but Treasure Island edges out for sheer convenience to major attractions.

Winner: Treasure Island (Location Score: 9/10 vs 8/10)

Room Quality & Amenities

Park MGM features completely redesigned rooms with a contemporary, sophisticated aesthetic. All 2,700 rooms include luxury bedding, marble bathrooms with walk-in showers, and advanced technology integration. The property is entirely smoke-free, a significant advantage for many travelers. Treasure Island's rooms offer comfortable but more traditional accommodations, with recent renovations in the tower rooms but maintaining a more conventional Vegas style. While clean and functional, they lack the modern luxury of Park MGM.

Winner: Park MGM (Room Quality Score: 9/10 vs 7/10)

Dining Options

Park MGM stands as a culinary destination with Eataly's massive Italian marketplace, Best Friend by Roy Choi (Korean-Mexican fusion), Primrose French restaurant, and several casual options. The quality and diversity are exceptional. Treasure Island offers reliable but more conventional options including The Coffee Shop, Seafood Shack, and Phil's Italian Steak House. While perfectly adequate, it cannot match Park MGM's culinary ambition or variety.

Winner: Park MGM (Dining Score: 9/10 vs 7/10)

Entertainment & Nightlife

Park MGM features the Dolby Live theater hosting major concerts and residencies, along with several sophisticated bars including the Juniper Cocktail Lounge. The atmosphere is more mature and refined. Treasure Island offers the long-running Mystère by Cirque du Soleil, along with more traditional casino entertainment and multiple bars. Its pirate theme provides family-friendly options that Park MGM lacks.

Winner: Treasure Island (Entertainment Score: 8/10 vs 9/10)

Value Proposition

Treasure Island consistently offers some of the best value on the Strip, with room rates typically 30-40% lower than Park MGM. The property provides solid amenities at a very competitive price point. Park MGM commands premium pricing that reflects its recent renovation, smoke-free environment, and superior dining options. While offering excellent quality, it comes at a significantly higher cost.

Winner: Treasure Island (Value Score: 7/10 vs 9/10)

Pool & Recreation

Park MGM features three elegant pools with cabanas and daybeds, offering a more sophisticated, adult-oriented atmosphere. The pools are smaller but well-appointed. Treasure Island's pool complex is larger and more family-friendly, with a fun, tropical theme and more recreational space. Both properties offer solid pool experiences catering to different demographics.

Winner: Split Decision (Pool Score: 8/10 vs 8/10)

Service Quality

Park MGM provides consistently excellent service with well-trained staff, efficient check-in processes, and attentive service throughout the property. Treasure Island offers friendly and competent service, though it can be less consistent during peak periods. Both properties maintain good service standards, but Park MGM demonstrates slightly higher polish.

Winner: Park MGM (Service Score: 9/10 vs 8/10)