New York-New York vs Treasure Island: Las Vegas Mid-Strip Hotel Showdown
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
Treasure Island Las Vegas Hotel & Casino
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (8.5/10) sits at the heart of the South Strip, offering immediate access to T-Mobile Arena, Park MGM, and the MGM Grand. Its central location makes walking to most major attractions feasible. Treasure Island (7/10) occupies a solid North Strip position with direct access to The Venetian and Fashion Show Mall, though it requires more transportation to reach southern attractions.
Winner: New York-New York
Room Quality & Comfort
New York-New York's 2,024 rooms (7/10) feature the iconic Manhattan skyline theme but show some wear in older sections. Standard rooms average 350-500 sq ft with comfortable bedding but dated bathrooms. Treasure Island's 2,884 rooms (8/10) underwent recent renovations featuring modern decor, plush bedding, and marble bathrooms. The TI rooms feel more luxurious and better maintained.
Winner: Treasure Island
Amenities & Facilities
New York-New York (8/10) boasts the famous Big Apple Roller Coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, and a massive casino floor. The pool area is adequate but often crowded. Treasure Island (7.5/10) features a more refined pool complex with cabanas, a quieter casino, and the Mystère by Cirque du Soleil theater. Both offer full-service spas and fitness centers.
Winner: New York-New York
Dining Options
New York-New York (8/10) offers diverse options including Tom's Urban, Gallagher's Steakhouse, and Nine Fine Irishmen pub. The food court provides quick, affordable choices. Treasure Island (7.5/10) features higher-end options like The Steak House and Señor Frog's, plus the Buffet TI. While fewer in number, TI's restaurants maintain higher quality standards.
Winner: New York-New York
Entertainment & Nightlife
New York-New York (8.5/10) excels with its roller coaster, live music at Nine Fine Irishmen, and proximity to T-Mobile Arena events. The atmosphere is energetic and family-friendly. Treasure Island (7/10) offers the acclaimed Mystère show and more sophisticated nightlife options like Gilley's Saloon, but lacks the same level of constant energy.
Winner: New York-New York
Value & Pricing
New York-New York (7/10) typically commands slightly higher room rates due to its premium location, though package deals with attraction tickets provide good value. Treasure Island (8.5/10) offers exceptional value with frequent room discounts, lower resort fees, and more inclusive pricing across dining and amenities.
Winner: Treasure Island
Service Quality
New York-New York (7.5/10) provides competent but sometimes rushed service due to higher guest volume. Check-in lines can be lengthy during peak times. Treasure Island (8/10) delivers more personalized service with shorter wait times and attentive staff, reflecting its slightly more upscale approach.
Winner: Treasure Island