New York-New York vs The Orleans: Comprehensive Las Vegas Hotel Comparison
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
The Orleans Hotel & Casino
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (Score: 9/10): Situated directly on the Las Vegas Strip, this property offers unparalleled access to major attractions, neighboring casinos, and the Las Vegas Monorail. Walking distance to T-Mobile Arena, Park MGM, and Excalibur. The central location comes with typical Strip congestion and noise.
The Orleans (Score: 7/10): Located about 2 miles west of the Strip, The Orleans requires transportation to access main attractions. However, it offers free parking and easier access to freeways. The area is less congested but lacks the immediate walkability of Strip properties.
Winner: New York-New York for superior location and convenience
Room Quality & Comfort
New York-New York (Score: 7/10): Rooms feature New York-inspired decor with comfortable bedding and modern amenities. Standard rooms average 350-450 sq ft. Some rooms show wear due to high occupancy, and noise from the roller coaster can be an issue in certain towers.
The Orleans (Score: 8/10): Recently renovated rooms offer more spacious accommodations (400-500 sq ft standard) with comfortable furnishings. The property maintains rooms well, and the off-Strip location provides quieter sleeping conditions. Bathrooms are more generously sized than NY-NY.
Winner: The Orleans for larger, quieter rooms
Amenities & Facilities
New York-New York (Score: 8/10): Features the famous Big Apple roller coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, multiple pools including a seasonal rooftop pool, full-service spa, fitness center, and extensive casino floor. The property excels in entertainment options and unique attractions.
The Orleans (Score: 8/10): Offers 18-screen movie theater, 70-lane bowling center, ice rink (seasonal), multiple pools, fitness center, and conference facilities. While lacking a roller coaster, it provides more diverse family entertainment options and meeting spaces.
Winner: Tie - Different strengths cater to different audiences
Dining Options
New York-New York (Score: 8/10): Features famous restaurants including Gallagher's Steakhouse, Il Fornaio, and Nine Fine Irishmen pub. Offers quick-service options like Nathan's Famous and authentic NYC-style pizza. Higher-end dining available but fewer budget options.
The Orleans (Score: 7/10): Provides diverse dining including Italian, Asian, steakhouse, and buffet options. More affordable casual dining choices including a food court. Lacks the celebrity chef restaurants found on the Strip but offers better value for money.
Winner: New York-New York for more upscale and diverse dining
Value & Pricing
New York-New York (Score: 6/10): Room rates typically range from $100-300/night depending on season, with resort fees around $45/night. Dining and entertainment prices reflect Strip premium pricing. Good value for the location but overall more expensive.
The Orleans (Score: 9/10): Rooms typically $60-150/night with lower resort fees ($30-35/night). Significantly more affordable dining, parking, and entertainment options. Excellent value proposition, especially for families and longer stays.
Winner: The Orleans for superior overall value
Service Quality
New York-New York (Score: 7/10): Generally efficient service but can be inconsistent during peak periods due to high volume. Staff are professional but may feel rushed. Check-in lines can be lengthy during conventions and weekends.
The Orleans (Score: 8/10): Known for friendly, attentive service with more personalized attention. Lower guest-to-staff ratio allows for better service recovery and attention to detail. Consistently receives high marks for customer service.
Winner: The Orleans for more consistent, personalized service
Atmosphere & Theme
New York-New York (Score: 9/10): Immersive New York City theme with replica landmarks, cobblestone streets, and skyline views. Energetic, exciting atmosphere perfect for adults seeking Vegas excitement. Can feel crowded and overwhelming for some.
The Orleans (Score: 7/10): New Orleans-themed with Mardi Gras decor and jazz influences. More relaxed, casual atmosphere suitable for families and older guests. Lacks the intensity and excitement of Strip properties but offers comfortable, welcoming environment.
Winner: New York-New York for superior theme execution and excitement