New York-New York vs The Cromwell: Themed Mega-Resort vs Boutique Luxury
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
The Cromwell
Room Quality & Design
New York-New York (Score: 7/10) features 2,024 rooms with recently renovated accommodations. Standard rooms average 350-500 sq ft with comfortable bedding, modern bathrooms, and NYC-inspired decor. The renovations have improved quality, though some rooms still show wear from high traffic.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) offers 188 boutique rooms starting at 360 sq ft, all featuring custom-designed furniture, marble bathrooms with rainforest showers, and sophisticated Parisian-inspired decor. The smaller room count ensures better maintenance and more personalized attention to detail.
Winner: The Cromwell - Superior materials, design sophistication, and consistent maintenance
Amenities & Facilities
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) boasts an incredible array of amenities: a full-sized roller coaster, 84,000 sq ft casino, multiple pools, spa, fitness center, wedding chapel, and direct access to Park MGM's entertainment options. The property functions as a self-contained entertainment destination.
The Cromwell (Score: 7/10) offers a more curated experience: a sophisticated casino floor, rooftop pool with dayclub, fitness center, and direct connection to LINQ Promenade. The amenities are high-quality but limited in variety compared to larger resorts.
Winner: New York-New York - Unmatched variety and family-friendly attractions
Dining Options
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) features over 15 dining options including Tom's Urban, Gallagher's Steakhouse, Nine Fine Irishmen pub, and a food court with NYC classics like pizza and deli sandwiches. Offers good variety across price points.
The Cromwell (Score: 8/10) is home to Giada De Laurentiis's restaurant and Bound by Saloon, offering elevated Italian cuisine and craft cocktails. While fewer options, the quality is exceptional. Guests also have easy access to LINQ Promenade's numerous restaurants.
Winner: Tie - NYNY wins on variety, Cromwell on quality and sophistication
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) sits at the south end of the Strip with monorail access, connected walkways to Excalibur and Park MGM, and easy freeway access. Slightly farther from center Strip attractions but well-connected.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) enjoys prime center Strip location at Flamingo and Las Vegas Boulevard, directly connected to Caesars Forum Shops and LINQ Promenade. Walking distance to Bellagio, Caesars, and Flamingo.
Winner: The Cromwell - Superior walking access to major Strip attractions
Service Quality
New York-New York (Score: 7/10) provides competent but sometimes impersonal service due to the property's massive scale. Check-in lines can be long during peak times, though staff are generally helpful.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) offers personalized, attentive service with quicker check-in, knowledgeable staff, and a more intimate atmosphere. The smaller property size allows for better guest recognition and service consistency.
Winner: The Cromwell - Consistently superior personalized service
Value Proposition
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) provides exceptional value with room rates typically $100-200/night, numerous free attractions, and affordable dining options. The entertainment value per dollar is among the best on the Strip.
The Cromwell (Score: 6/10) commands premium pricing ($250-400/night) reflecting its boutique luxury positioning. While the experience is elevated, the value proposition is less compelling for budget-conscious travelers.
Winner: New York-New York - Far superior entertainment value and affordability
Atmosphere & Vibe
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) delivers energetic, family-friendly excitement with its bustling casino, roller coaster screams, and constant activity. The NYC theme creates a fun, immersive environment that appeals to a broad audience.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10) offers a sophisticated, adults-oriented atmosphere with chic design, upscale gaming, and trendy nightlife. The vibe is more intimate and luxurious, appealing to couples and sophisticated travelers.
Winner: The Cromwell - More refined and consistently upscale atmosphere