New York-New York vs The Cromwell: Boutique Luxury vs Themed Family Resort Experience
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
The Cromwell
Overall Comparison
These two properties represent fundamentally different approaches to the Las Vegas hotel experience. New York-New York delivers a massive, themed resort catering to families and budget-conscious travelers, while The Cromwell offers an intimate, boutique luxury experience targeting sophisticated adults.
Room Quality & Design
New York-New York (Score: 7/10): Rooms feature standard hotel accommodations with New York-themed decor. Recently renovated rooms offer modern amenities but maintain the property's signature theme. Standard rooms average 350-450 sq ft with comfortable bedding and functional layouts.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10): Boutique-style rooms designed by David Rockwell feature custom furnishings, hardwood floors, and sophisticated Parisian-inspired decor. Rooms range from 360-750 sq ft with premium linens, marble bathrooms, and exclusive amenities.
Winner: The Cromwell
Dining Options
New York-New York (Score: 8/10): Features over 10 dining options including Gallagher's Steakhouse, Nine Fine Irishmen, and casual options like Nathan's Famous and pizza outlets. Diverse offerings cater to various tastes and budgets.
The Cromwell (Score: 8/10): Home to Giada De Laurentiis's restaurant and Bound by Saloon, offering elevated Italian cuisine and craft cocktails. Fewer options but higher quality execution and atmosphere.
Winner: Tie - Depends on preference for variety vs quality
Entertainment & Amenities
New York-New York (Score: 9/10): Features the iconic roller coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, numerous bars, large casino, and Big Apple-themed shopping arcade. Pool area includes multiple pools and cabanas.
The Cromwell (Score: 7/10): Offers Drai's Beach Club & Nightclub, a sophisticated casino, and intimate bars. More limited amenities but higher-end execution targeting adult guests.
Winner: New York-New York
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (Score: 8/10): South Strip location connected to Excalibur and MGM Grand via pedestrian bridges. Requires more walking to reach center Strip attractions.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10): Prime center Strip location adjacent to Flamingo and across from Caesars Palace. Steps from Bellagio fountains and highest concentration of attractions.
Winner: The Cromwell
Value for Money
New York-New York (Score: 9/10): Typically offers rooms starting around $100/night midweek, providing excellent value given the extensive amenities and large room sizes.
The Cromwell (Score: 6/10): Rooms typically start around $250/night, positioning it as a luxury option. Better value emerges during promotional periods.
Winner: New York-New York
Service Quality
New York-New York (Score: 7/10): Competent but sometimes overwhelmed service due to property size. Check-in can experience delays during peak periods.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10): Excellent personalized service with higher staff-to-guest ratio. Attentive concierge and quicker check-in experiences.
Winner: The Cromwell
Target Audience Suitability
New York-New York: Ideal for families, budget travelers, and those seeking lively atmosphere and numerous entertainment options.
The Cromwell: Perfect for couples, luxury seekers, and adults preferring sophisticated, intimate environments.