New York-New York vs The Cromwell: A Tale of Themed Family Fun vs Boutique Luxury
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
The Cromwell
Comprehensive Comparison: New York-New York vs The Cromwell
Room Quality & Design
New York-New York (Score: 7/10): Features 2,024 rooms with recently renovated accommodations. Rooms maintain the NYC theme with skyline views, comfortable bedding, and functional layouts. Standard rooms average 350-450 sq ft with basic amenities. While clean and well-maintained, the decor can feel dated in some areas and noise from the roller coaster can be an issue for light sleepers.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10): Offers 188 boutique rooms with sophisticated Parisian-inspired design. Rooms feature hardwood floors, custom furnishings, and luxurious marble bathrooms. Standard rooms start at 400 sq ft with premium amenities including iPads for room control. The intimate scale ensures superior soundproofing and exclusivity.
Winner: The Cromwell for superior design and luxury
Dining Options
New York-New York (Score: 8/10): Features diverse casual dining including Nine Fine Irishmen, Gallagher's Steakhouse, and authentic NYC-style pizza. The food court offers quick options like Nathan's Famous and Haagen-Dazs. Lacks fine dining but provides excellent variety for families and casual travelers.
The Cromwell (Score: 8/10): Home to Giada De Laurentiis's restaurant and Bound by Salton Sea seafood. The Interlude lounge offers craft cocktails. While fewer options, the quality is exceptional. Drai's Beach Club provides daytime dining. Limited casual options but premium quality throughout.
Winner: Tie - NYNY for variety, Cromwell for quality
Entertainment & Amenities
New York-New York (Score: 9/10): Features the iconic Big Apple Coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, and extensive casino floor. Multiple bars and live music at Nine Fine Irishmen. Pool area is adequate but can get crowded. Excellent for families and thrill-seekers.
The Cromwell (Score: 8/10): Home to the legendary Drai's Nightclub and Beach Club. Intimate casino floor with higher table limits. Rooftop pool with dayclub experience. Focused on nightlife and adult entertainment rather than family activities.
Winner: New York-New York for broader appeal
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (Score: 9/10): South Strip location connected to Park MGM via bridge. Direct access to MGM Grand and Excalibur. Monorail station nearby. Excellent pedestrian access to T-Mobile Arena and other south Strip properties.
The Cromwell (Score: 10/10): Prime center Strip location across from Caesars Palace and next to Flamingo. Steps from Bellagio fountains and Linq Promenade. Best possible walking score to major attractions. Direct pedestrian access to most center Strip destinations.
Winner: The Cromwell for superior center Strip positioning
Service & Staff
New York-New York (Score: 7/10): Generally efficient but can be inconsistent during peak times. Check-in lines can be long. Staff are friendly but stretched thin during conventions and busy weekends. Housekeeping is reliable but not exceptional.
The Cromwell (Score: 9/10): Exceptional personalized service with higher staff-to-guest ratio. Concierge provides white-glove service. Quick check-in and attentive staff throughout. Housekeeping is meticulous with turndown service available.
Winner: The Cromwell for superior service quality
Value & Pricing
New York-New York (Score: 9/10): Excellent value with rooms often $100-200/night. Resort fees are standard but reasonable. Dining and entertainment options provide good value. Frequent package deals and promotions available.
The Cromwell (Score: 6/10): Premium pricing with rooms typically $250-400/night. Higher resort fees and minimums. Dining and nightlife are expensive but high-quality. Best value for those seeking luxury experience.
Winner: New York-New York for overall value