New York-New York vs Red Rock Casino Resort: Strip Excitement vs Off-Strip Luxury
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
Red Rock Casino, Resort and Spa
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) sits at the heart of the Las Vegas Strip, offering unparalleled access to major attractions, shopping, and entertainment. The hotel connects to Park MGM and is within walking distance of T-Mobile Arena, Excalibur, and MGM Grand. The monorail station provides additional transportation options.
Red Rock Casino (Score: 7/10) is located 10 miles west of the Strip in Summerlin, requiring transportation to reach main tourist areas. However, its location offers stunning views of the Red Rock Canyon and provides a peaceful retreat from Strip chaos.
Winner: New York-New York for tourists seeking convenience
Accommodations & Room Quality
New York-New York (Score: 7/10) features 2,024 rooms with New York-themed decor. Standard rooms are comfortable but show some wear, averaging 350-500 sq ft. Recent renovations have updated some rooms with modern amenities.
Red Rock Casino (Score: 9/10) offers 816 spacious, luxury rooms and suites ranging from 500-3,000 sq ft. Rooms feature premium bedding, marble bathrooms, and contemporary furnishings with high-end finishes throughout.
Winner: Red Rock Casino for superior room quality and comfort
Dining Options
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) offers diverse dining including Gallagher's Steakhouse, Il Fornaio, and Nine Fine Irishmen pub. The food court provides quick options, and nearby Strip restaurants are easily accessible.
Red Rock Casino (Score: 9/10) features award-winning restaurants including T-Bones Chophouse, Hearthstone Kitchen, and Lotus of Siam. The resort emphasizes quality over quantity with several upscale dining options.
Winner: Red Rock Casino for culinary excellence
Entertainment & Amenities
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) boasts the iconic roller coaster, Big Apple Arcade, and Zumanity theater show. The casino floor is vibrant, and the property features multiple bars and lounges with live entertainment.
Red Rock Casino (Score: 8/10) offers 16-screen movie theater, bowling alley, and luxury spa. The pool complex is expansive with cabanas and a beach club atmosphere. The casino focuses on high-limit gaming and premium experiences.
Winner: Tie - both excel in different entertainment aspects
Value & Pricing
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) offers mid-range pricing with rooms typically $100-250/night. Resort fees are standard for Strip properties. Good value for the location and amenities provided.
Red Rock Casino (Score: 6/10) commands premium pricing at $200-400/night with higher-end dining and amenities. The value proposition lies in luxury experience rather than budget-friendly options.
Winner: New York-New York for better overall value
Service Quality
New York-New York (Score: 7/10) provides competent but sometimes rushed service due to high volume. Staff are generally helpful but service levels can vary during peak times.
Red Rock Casino (Score: 9/10) delivers exceptional service with higher staff-to-guest ratios. Attentive concierge, prompt room service, and personalized attention throughout the property.
Winner: Red Rock Casino for superior service quality