New York-New York vs Planet Hollywood: Las Vegas Mid-Strip Hotel Showdown

Room Quality & Comfort

New York-New York's 2,024 rooms feature a classic New York aesthetic with dark wood furnishings and cityscape themes. Standard rooms average 350-500 sq ft with comfortable pillow-top mattresses. Recent renovations have updated bathrooms with marble accents. Soundproofing can be inconsistent in rooms near the roller coaster.

Planet Hollywood's 2,500 rooms showcase a contemporary Hollywood glam style with platform beds and vibrant colors. Rooms are slightly larger at 400-550 sq ft with superior soundproofing and modern technology including smart TVs. Bathrooms feature spacious glass-enclosed showers and premium amenities.

Winner: Planet Hollywood (8.5/10 vs 7/10)

Amenities & Facilities

New York-New York features the iconic Big Apple Roller Coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, and a 84,000 sq ft casino. The pool area includes multiple pools with a Coney Island theme but lacks cabana privacy. The spa is adequate but smaller than competitors.

Planet Hollywood offers the Miracle Mile Shops with 170 stores, a larger 95,000 sq ft casino, and the AXIS theater. The pool deck includes private cabanas and a more sophisticated atmosphere. The spa is more extensive with additional treatment options.

Winner: Planet Hollywood (9/10 vs 8/10)

Dining Options

New York-New York features classic NYC eateries including Gallagher's Steakhouse, Il Fornaio, and Nine Fine Irishmen pub. The food court offers quick options like Nathan's Famous and Greenwich Village-style pizza. Overall quality is good but lacks celebrity chef restaurants.

Planet Hollywood excels with celebrity dining including Gordon Ramsay Burger, KOI Restaurant, and Strip House Steakhouse. The food court is more upscale with options like Earl of Sandwich. Overall offers more diverse and higher-end culinary experiences.

Winner: Planet Hollywood (9/10 vs 7.5/10)

Location & Accessibility

New York-New York sits at the south end of Mid-Strip with direct connections to Excalibur and MGM Grand via pedestrian bridges. Slightly longer walks to northern properties but excellent monorail access. Better for those preferring slightly less crowded areas.

Planet Hollywood occupies prime center-Strip location directly across from Bellagio fountains and connected to Miracle Mile Shops. Superior walking access to Caesars Palace, Cosmopolitan, and Bellagio. More central but also more crowded.

Winner: Planet Hollywood (10/10 vs 8/10)

Value & Pricing

New York-New York offers significantly better value with room rates typically $50-100 less than comparable Strip properties. Resort fees are standard but overall costs for dining and entertainment are more moderate. Better for budget-conscious travelers.

Planet Hollywood commands premium pricing reflecting its superior location and amenities. Room rates run $50-150 higher than NY-NY depending on season. Dining and shopping also trend more expensive throughout the property.

Winner: New York-New York (9/10 vs 6/10)

Service Quality

New York-New York provides consistent, friendly service with efficient check-in and housekeeping. Staff maintains the energetic New York attitude though can be less attentive during peak periods. Casino service is prompt and professional.

Planet Hollywood offers more polished service with concierge support for show tickets and dining reservations. Housekeeping attention to detail is superior. Staff training reflects the more upscale positioning of the property.

Winner: Planet Hollywood (8.5/10 vs 7.5/10)