New York-New York vs Park MGM: A Comprehensive Las Vegas Hotel Showdown
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
Park MGM Las Vegas
Room Quality & Accommodations
New York-New York features 2,024 rooms with a distinctive NYC theme. Standard rooms (380 sq ft) include skyline views, pillow-top mattresses, and marble bathrooms. The decor is bold with Empire State Building accents but shows some wear in older sections. Park MGM offers 2,700 rooms with a more sophisticated, contemporary design. Standard rooms (400 sq ft) feature plush bedding, marble bathrooms with walk-in showers, and smart technology integration. Rooms are noticeably newer and better soundproofed.
Winner: Park MGM (8.5 vs 7.0)
Dining Options
New York-New York features casual eateries including Nine Fine Irishmen, Gallagher's Steakhouse, and a food court with Shake Shack and pizza. Options are plentiful but lean toward casual dining. Park MGM is a culinary destination with Eataly (40,000 sq ft Italian marketplace), Best Friend (Korean BBQ by Roy Choi), and Primrose French restaurant. Also features Bavette's Steakhouse and on-property Starbucks.
Winner: Park MGM (9.0 vs 7.5)
Entertainment & Amenities
New York-New York boasts the Big Apple Coaster (1,144 ft roller coaster), Hershey's Chocolate World, and a 84,000 sq ft casino. The pool area is Coney Island-themed with water slides. Park MGM features the Dolby Live theater (5,200 seats hosting major acts), no-smoking casino policy, and three sophisticated pools with cabanas. Lacks thrill rides but offers higher-end entertainment.
Winner: New York-New York (8.5 vs 8.0)
Service Quality
New York-New York provides friendly, efficient service with 24-hour front desk and concierge. Housekeeping is reliable but can be inconsistent during peak periods. Park MGM offers elevated service with personalized check-in, attentive staff, and enhanced housekeeping standards. The smoke-free environment contributes to cleaner public areas.
Winner: Park MGM (8.5 vs 7.5)
Location & Accessibility
Both properties enjoy prime South Strip locations. New York-New York connects to MGM Grand via pedestrian bridge and is adjacent to T-Mobile Arena. Park MGM connects directly to Aria and Bellagio via complimentary trams and pedestrian walkways, providing superior access to luxury shopping and dining.
Winner: Park MGM (9.5 vs 9.0)
Value Proposition
New York-New York offers rooms starting at $79-$129 weeknights, with lower resort fees ($39 vs $45). Dining and entertainment are more affordable. Park MGM commands higher rates ($129-$199 weeknights) but delivers superior quality and included amenities like fitness center access.
Winner: New York-New York (8.5 vs 7.0)
Family Friendliness
New York-New York excels with roller coaster, arcade, and pool slides. Room configurations accommodate families better. Park MGM's sophisticated atmosphere and lack of child-focused amenities make it better suited for adults and couples.
Winner: New York-New York (9.0 vs 6.5)