New York-New York vs Gold Coast: Themed Luxury vs Local Value Hotel Comparison
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
Gold Coast Hotel and Casino
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York enjoys a prime South Strip location with direct access to the pedestrian bridge network connecting to neighboring properties. The hotel sits adjacent to T-Mobile Arena and Park MGM, placing guests within walking distance of major attractions. Gold Coast is located approximately one mile west of the Strip on Flamingo Road, requiring transportation to reach main tourist areas but offering easier freeway access and proximity to the Las Vegas Convention Center.
Winner: New York-New York (8.5/10 vs 6/10)
Rooms & Accommodations
New York-New York features 2,024 rooms with recently renovated interiors showcasing modern New York-inspired decor. Standard rooms average 350-500 sq ft with premium linens, marble bathrooms, and skyline views. Gold Coast offers 711 rooms with more traditional, functional layouts averaging 300-400 sq ft. While clean and comfortable, the decor shows its age compared to the recently refreshed NY-NY rooms.
Winner: New York-New York (8/10 vs 6.5/10)
Amenities & Facilities
New York-New York boasts the iconic Big Apple Roller Coaster, full-service spa, multiple swimming pools, and a 84,000 sq ft casino. The property features extensive meeting spaces and wedding chapels. Gold Coast offers a more intimate casino experience, bowling alley, movie theater, and outdoor pool. While less extravagant, it provides unique local entertainment options not found at Strip properties.
Winner: New York-New York (9/10 vs 7/10)
Dining Options
New York-New York features 15 dining venues including Tom's Urban, Gallagher's Steakhouse, and authentic NYC-style pizza shops. The property offers diverse culinary experiences from quick service to fine dining. Gold Coast provides 9 restaurants including the popular Ports O' Call buffet, Ping Pang Pong Chinese restaurant, and several casual eateries offering better value for money.
Winner: New York-New York (8.5/10 vs 7.5/10)
Entertainment & Nightlife
New York-New York features the Broadway Theater hosting major productions, multiple bars including the popular Nine Fine Irishmen pub with live music, and the roller coaster attraction. The property benefits from proximity to other Strip entertainment. Gold Coast offers bingo hall, bowling center, and regular local entertainment events at more affordable prices than Strip venues.
Winner: New York-New York (9/10 vs 7/10)
Value & Pricing
New York-New York commands premium Strip pricing with rooms typically starting at $150-300/night plus resort fees. Dining and entertainment prices align with Strip averages. Gold Coast offers exceptional value with rooms often available under $100/night, lower resort fees, and significantly more affordable dining and gaming options.
Winner: Gold Coast (6/10 vs 9/10)
Target Audience & Atmosphere
New York-New York attracts tourists seeking the full Vegas Strip experience with its energetic, theme-park-like atmosphere appealing to couples, groups, and families with older children. Gold Coast caters to budget-conscious travelers, locals, and seniors seeking a more relaxed, traditional casino hotel experience away from Strip crowds.
Winner: Split Decision