New York-New York vs Fremont Hotel: Themed Strip Resort vs Classic Downtown Experience
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
Fremont Hotel & Casino
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) sits prominently on the South Strip, offering immediate access to major attractions like T-Mobile Arena, Park MGM, and the iconic Las Vegas Boulevard. The monorail station and Deuce bus stop provide excellent transportation options. However, traffic congestion can be challenging during peak hours.
Fremont Hotel (Score: 7/10) is nestled in the heart of Downtown's Fremont Street Experience, surrounded by historic casinos and vibrant street performances. While offering authentic old Vegas charm, it's farther from Strip attractions (15-20 minute drive) and has limited public transportation options compared to the Strip.
Winner: New York-New York for superior accessibility and proximity to major attractions
Room Quality & Amenities
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) features 2,024 recently renovated rooms with NYC-inspired decor. Standard rooms average 350-500 sq ft with comfortable bedding, modern bathrooms, and skyline views. Amenities include 24-hour room service, daily housekeeping, and pet-friendly options (with fee).
Fremont Hotel (Score: 6/10) offers 447 simpler, smaller rooms (average 300-400 sq ft) with retro Vegas charm. While clean and functional, rooms show some age and lack the modern luxury of Strip properties. Basic amenities include daily housekeeping but lack 24-hour room service.
Winner: New York-New York for superior room quality and amenities
Dining Options
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) boasts over 15 dining venues including Tom's Urban, Gallagher's Steakhouse, and authentic NYC-style pizza at Gonzalez y Gonzalez. The food court offers quick options, and the resort connects to additional choices at Park MGM.
Fremont Hotel (Score: 6/10) features more limited options including Second Street Grill, Tony Roma's, and a 24-hour coffee shop. While satisfying basic needs, it lacks the variety and upscale choices available on the Strip.
Winner: New York-New York for variety and quality of dining
Entertainment & Casino
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) features the thrilling Big Apple Coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, and a 84,000 sq ft casino with all major table games and slots. The resort frequently hosts live entertainment and benefits from proximity to T-Mobile Arena events.
Fremont Hotel (Score: 7/10) offers a more intimate 32,000 sq ft casino with favorable odds and lower minimum bets. While lacking major attractions, it provides direct access to the Fremont Street Experience's free concerts and light shows.
Winner: New York-New York for superior entertainment options
Value & Pricing
New York-New York (Score: 6/10) commands higher room rates ($120-300/night), resort fees ($45/night), and premium pricing for amenities. While offering more features, the cost is significantly higher than downtown options.
Fremont Hotel (Score: 9/10) provides exceptional value with rooms typically $50-150/night and lower resort fees ($25/night). Gaming minimums are lower, and dining/drinks are considerably more affordable.
Winner: Fremont Hotel for superior overall value
Service Quality
New York-New York (Score: 7/10) offers professional but sometimes impersonal service typical of large Strip resorts. Check-in lines can be long during peak times, though staff are generally efficient and knowledgeable.
Fremont Hotel (Score: 8/10) provides more personalized service with shorter wait times and friendly staff who often remember returning guests. The smaller scale allows for more attentive service.
Winner: Fremont Hotel for more personalized service