New York-New York Hotel & Casino vs the D Las Vegas: Comprehensive Hotel Comparison
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
the D Las Vegas
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) occupies a prime South Strip location with direct access to the MGM Grand monorail station and walking distance to T-Mobile Arena, Park MGM, and Excalibur. Its central Strip position provides unparalleled access to major attractions, though traffic congestion can be challenging.
the D Las Vegas (Score: 7/10) sits in the heart of Fremont Street Experience, offering immediate access to downtown's vibrant nightlife and historic casinos. While lacking the Strip's glamour, it provides easier navigation and cheaper rideshare options to the Strip (15-20 minutes).
Winner: New York-New York for superior overall accessibility
Accommodations & Rooms
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) features 2,024 rooms across multiple towers with recently renovated accommodations. Standard rooms average 350-500 sq ft with comfortable bedding, modern bathrooms, and NYC-inspired decor. Noise from the roller coaster and casino can be noticeable in lower floors.
the D Las Vegas (Score: 7/10) offers 638 rooms with a modern, sleek design. Rooms are smaller (250-400 sq ft) but efficiently designed with comfortable beds and contemporary amenities. The hotel's smaller size means quieter hallways and faster elevator access.
Winner: New York-New York for larger rooms and more variety
Dining Options
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) boasts over 15 dining venues including Tom's Urban, Gallagher's Steakhouse, and Nine Fine Irishmen. Offers diverse options from quick-service pizza and delis to upscale dining, plus a full food court and 24-hour options.
the D Las Vegas (Score: 6/10) features more limited but quality options including Andiamo Steakhouse, American Coney Island, and a casino bar menu. Lacks variety but provides solid dining experiences at more affordable prices.
Winner: New York-New York for superior variety and quality
Casino & Gaming
New York-New York (Score: 8/10) features a 84,000 sq ft casino with 1,200 slots, 67 table games, and a dedicated poker room. Higher table limits and more variety, but can feel crowded and overwhelming during peak hours.
the D Las Vegas (Score: 9/10) offers a more intimate 50,000 sq ft casino with 600 slots and 25 table games. Known for its friendly dealers, lower minimums, and unique vintage slot collection. The two-level casino design creates a less crowded experience.
Winner: the D Las Vegas for better player experience and value
Entertainment & Amenities
New York-New York (Score: 9/10) features the iconic Big Apple Roller Coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, multiple pools including a resort-style pool complex, spa, fitness center, and shopping arcade. Offers Broadway-style shows and regular entertainment.
the D Las Vegas (Score: 7/10) provides access to Fremont Street entertainment, a rooftop pool, modern fitness center, and the unique Long Bar. Lacks extensive on-site entertainment but benefits from downtown's constant free entertainment offerings.
Winner: New York-New York for superior on-site amenities
Service & Staff
New York-New York (Score: 7/10) provides competent but sometimes impersonal service due to its size. Check-in lines can be lengthy, though staff are generally professional and efficient. Housekeeping standards are consistently good.
the D Las Vegas (Score: 9/10) excels in personalized service with friendly, attentive staff. Smaller size allows for more guest interaction and quicker response times. Consistently receives praise for exceptional customer service.
Winner: the D Las Vegas for superior personalized service
Value & Pricing
New York-New York (Score: 7/10) offers mid-range Strip pricing with rooms typically $100-250/night. Resort fees are standard ($45-55/night). Good value for the location and amenities, though food and gaming can be pricey.
the D Las Vegas (Score: 9/10) provides exceptional value with rooms often $50-150/night and lower resort fees ($35-45/night). Significantly cheaper dining, drinks, and gaming make it a budget-friendly option without sacrificing quality.
Winner: the D Las Vegas for overall value proposition