New York-New York Hotel & Casino vs Sam's Town Hotel & Gambling Hall: The Strip Experience vs Off-Strip Value
New York-New York Hotel & Casino
Sam's Town Hotel & Gambling Hall
Location & Accessibility
New York-New York (9/10) sits prominently on the Las Vegas Strip between MGM Grand and Excalibur, offering unparalleled walkability to major attractions. The hotel connects via pedestrian bridges to neighboring properties and the Park MGM monorail station. Sam's Town (6/10) is located in East Las Vegas, approximately 15 minutes from the Strip by car. While it offers free parking and shuttle service, the location requires transportation for accessing main tourist areas.
Winner: New York-New York
Accommodations & Room Quality
New York-New York (8/10) features 2,024 rooms with recently renovated interiors featuring modern decor with NYC-inspired accents. Standard rooms average 350-500 sq ft with comfortable bedding and city or Strip views. Sam's Town (7/10) offers 650 larger rooms averaging 400-600 sq ft with more traditional decor. Rooms are well-maintained but show some age in furnishings.
Winner: New York-New York (by slight margin)
Dining Options
New York-New York (9/10) boasts diverse dining including Tom's Urban, Gallagher's Steakhouse, Nine Fine Irishmen pub, and authentic NYC-style pizza. The property offers over 15 dining options ranging from quick service to fine dining. Sam's Town (7/10) features more budget-conscious options including Willy & Jose's Mexican Cantina, Firelight Buffet, and several casual restaurants. Quality is good but variety is more limited.
Winner: New York-New York
Entertainment & Amenities
New York-New York (9/10) features the iconic roller coaster, Hershey's Chocolate World, Broadway-style shows at the theater, and a massive casino floor. The pool complex includes multiple pools and cabanas. Sam's Town (8/10) offers the stunning Mystic Falls Park with laser shows, 56-lane bowling center, 18-screen movie theater, and larger gambling area. The Golden Age West theater hosts regular entertainment.
Winner: New York-New York (for variety)
Value & Pricing
New York-New York (6/10) commands premium pricing with rooms averaging $150-300/night, plus resort fees and expensive dining. Sam's Town (9/10) offers exceptional value with rooms typically $60-120/night, lower resort fees, and more affordable dining and gambling options.
Winner: Sam's Town
Atmosphere & Clientele
New York-New York (8/10) maintains an energetic, tourist-focused atmosphere with constant activity and international visitors. The NYC theme creates an immersive experience. Sam's Town (8/10) offers a more relaxed, local-friendly environment with primarily regional visitors and regulars. The Western theme provides comfortable, familiar surroundings.
Winner: Tie (depends on preference)
Practical Information
New York-New York: Resort fee ~$45/night, self-parking $18-23/day, valet $30-35/day. Best for couples, groups, and first-time visitors wanting the full Vegas experience. Sam's Town: Resort fee ~$25/night, free self-parking, no valet. Ideal for budget-conscious travelers, families, and those preferring quieter accommodations.