Mandalay Bay vs Treasure Island: Comprehensive Las Vegas Resort Comparison
Mandalay Bay Resort and Casino
Treasure Island Las Vegas Hotel & Casino
Accommodations Comparison
Mandalay Bay: Features 3,211 rooms including 424 suites with contemporary decor and floor-to-ceiling windows. Standard rooms average 550 sq ft with luxurious bedding and marble bathrooms. The Four Seasons and THEhotel components offer premium options.
Treasure Island: Offers 2,884 rooms with pirate-themed or contemporary decor. Rooms average 450 sq ft with comfortable bedding and standard amenities. More budget-friendly but less luxurious than Mandalay Bay.
Winner: Mandalay Bay (9/10 vs 7/10)
Amenities and Facilities
Mandalay Bay: World-class 11-acre beach complex with wave pool, lazy river, and multiple pools. Mandalay Bay Convention Center (1.7M sq ft), full-service spa, fitness center, and Shark Reef Aquarium.
Treasure Island: Single large pool with cabanas, smaller fitness center, and basic spa services. More limited recreational options but adequate for most visitors.
Winner: Mandalay Bay (10/10 vs 6/10)
Dining Options
Mandalay Bay: 21 restaurants including fine dining (Aureole, Fleur by Hubert Keller), celebrity chef establishments, and diverse casual options. Extensive variety for all budgets.
Treasure Island: 10 restaurants including The Coffee Shop, Pho & Banh Mi, and Gilley's Saloon. More limited upscale options but good mid-range choices.
Winner: Mandalay Bay (9/10 vs 7/10)
Entertainment and Nightlife
Mandalay Bay: House of Blues concert venue, Daylight Beach Club, and Mandalay Bay Events Center hosting major concerts and sporting events.
Treasure Island: Mystère by Cirque du Soleil, Kahunaville nightclub, and regular pirate show entertainment. Strong entertainment value.
Winner: Treasure Island (8/10 vs 9/10)
Location and Accessibility
Mandalay Bay: South Strip location requires more walking or transportation to central attractions but connects to Luxor and Excalibur via tram. More secluded atmosphere.
Treasure Island: Prime mid-Strip location adjacent to The Venetian and Mirage. Walking distance to Fashion Show Mall and Forum Shops. Superior accessibility.
Winner: Treasure Island (7/10 vs 9/10)
Value and Pricing
Mandalay Bay: Higher room rates ($150-400/night) but offers premium amenities. Better value for luxury seekers.
Treasure Island: More affordable ($100-250/night) with good mid-range offerings. Excellent budget-to-mid-range value.
Winner: Treasure Island (7/10 vs 9/10)
Casino Experience
Mandalay Bay: 135,000 sq ft casino with high-limit areas, race and sports book, and poker room. More upscale gaming environment.
Treasure Island: 95,000 sq ft casino with friendly atmosphere, lower table minimums, and popular slot selection. More accessible for casual gamers.
Winner: Mandalay Bay (9/10 vs 8/10)