Horseshoe Las Vegas vs Treasure Island: Mid-Strip Value vs Family-Friendly Luxury

Location & Accessibility

Horseshoe Las Vegas boasts arguably the best location on the Strip, directly connected to Paris Las Vegas and steps from Bellagio's fountains. The monorail station provides easy north-south access. Score: 9/10

Treasure Island sits at the north end of the Strip near Fashion Show Mall, requiring more walking to central attractions but offering slightly easier vehicle access. Score: 7/10

Winner: Horseshoe Las Vegas

Room Quality & Amenities

Horseshoe rooms show their age (built 1973) with basic furnishings but clean, functional layouts. Recent renovations have modernized bathrooms. Score: 6/10

Treasure Island features recently remodeled rooms with plush bedding, marble bathrooms, and contemporary decor. Significantly more luxurious feel. Score: 8/10

Winner: Treasure Island

Dining Options

Horseshoe offers budget-conscious options including a food court, steakhouse, and casual eateries. Lacks signature fine dining. Score: 6/10

Treasure Island features higher-end options like The Coffee Shop, Pho Vietnamese, and seafood restaurant. Better quality but fewer choices. Score: 7/10

Winner: Treasure Island

Entertainment & Amenities

Horseshoe focuses on gambling with a massive casino floor. Connected to Paris's pool complex. Limited show options. Score: 7/10

Treasure Island offers the Mystère by Cirque du Soleil show, better pool atmosphere, and more family-friendly facilities. Score: 8/10

Winner: Treasure Island

Value for Money

Horseshoe provides exceptional value with rooms often $50-100 less than comparable properties. Center-Strip location at budget prices. Score: 9/10

Treasure Island commands premium pricing ($50-150 more per night) for superior amenities but isn't the Strip's best luxury value. Score: 6/10

Winner: Horseshoe Las Vegas

Service Quality

Horseshoe staff provide efficient but basic service. Check-in lines can be long during peak times. Score: 6/10

Treasure Island offers more attentive service with quicker check-in, better housekeeping, and more responsive staff. Score: 8/10

Winner: Treasure Island