Horseshoe Las Vegas vs the D Las Vegas: A Downtown Duel of Value and Vibe
Horseshoe Las Vegas
the D Las Vegas
Location & Accessibility
Both properties sit at the heart of the Fremont Street Experience, placing guests steps from downtown's iconic light show, live music, and pedestrian mall. The Horseshoe occupies a central position with direct access to the experience, while the D's location on the corner of Fremont and 1st Street offers excellent people-watching opportunities. Both are easily accessible from I-15 and within walking distance of all downtown attractions.
Winner: Tie (Both score 9/10)
Rooms & Accommodations
Horseshoe's rooms are surprisingly spacious (starting at 350 sq ft) with comfortable bedding and functional layouts, though decor shows some age. The D offers more contemporary rooms with modern furnishings, USB charging ports, and better soundproofing. Standard rooms at the D are slightly smaller but feel more updated. Both properties offer clean, well-maintained accommodations.
Winner: the D Las Vegas (Horseshoe: 7/10, the D: 8/10)
Dining Options
Horseshoe features Jack Binion's Steak House (a downtown institution), several casual eateries, and a 24-hour coffee shop. The D counters with Andiamo Steakhouse, American Coney Island, and a popular pizza outlet. The D's food options feel more diverse and contemporary, though both properties lack the celebrity chef restaurants found on the Strip.
Winner: the D Las Vegas (Horseshoe: 6/10, the D: 8/10)
Casino & Gaming
Horseshoe's massive 50,000 sq ft casino features lower table limits and a wider variety of table games, appealing to serious gamblers. The D's casino is more modern with updated slot machines and a popular casino bar scene. Both offer complete casino experiences, but Horseshoe's larger floor and better odds give it the edge for dedicated gamers.
Winner: Horseshoe Las Vegas (Horseshoe: 9/10, the D: 8/10)
Entertainment & Nightlife
The D excels with its multi-level casino bar, Longbar (one of Nevada's longest bars), live music, and energetic atmosphere. Horseshoe offers more traditional casino entertainment with occasional shows in its showroom. The D's rooftop Vue Bar provides stunning downtown views unavailable at Horseshoe.
Winner: the D Las Vegas (Horseshoe: 6/10, the D: 9/10)
Value & Pricing
Horseshoe typically offers slightly lower room rates and better gaming promotions. Room rates average $20-40 less than the D's comparable rooms. Both properties provide excellent value compared to Strip hotels, but Horseshoe's consistent pricing and larger standard rooms deliver better bang for your buck.
Winner: Horseshoe Las Vegas (Horseshoe: 9/10, the D: 7/10)
Service & Amenities
Both properties provide competent but basic service typical of downtown casinos. The D's staff tends to be more attentive and responsive to guest needs. Horseshoe offers a seasonal pool, while the D lacks a pool entirely. Both have fitness centers and business facilities, though neither property excels in luxury amenities.
Winner: the D Las Vegas (Horseshoe: 6/10, the D: 7/10)