El Cortez vs Golden Gate: Historic Downtown Vegas Hotel Showdown

Historical Significance

El Cortez (opened 1941) holds the distinction of being the longest continuously operating hotel-casino in Las Vegas, with original ownership including mobster Bugsy Siegel. The property maintains much of its vintage 1940s character with classic neon signage and historic architecture. Golden Gate (opened 1906) actually predates El Cortez as Las Vegas' oldest hotel, originally opening as the Hotel Nevada. Both properties have undergone renovations while preserving their historical integrity.

Winner: Golden Gate (for being Vegas' original hotel)

Room Quality and Amenities

El Cortez offers 364 rooms across three categories: Cabana Suites, Classic rooms, and the newer Fremont Tower. Rooms range from basic but clean accommodations to more modern suites. The property features a seasonal outdoor pool, fitness center, and multiple dining options. Golden Gate's 122 rooms were completely renovated in 2012, featuring boutique-style accommodations with premium bedding and modern bathrooms. The property offers a more intimate experience with fewer amenities but higher-quality finishes.

Winner: Golden Gate (8/10 vs 6/10 for overall room quality)

Dining Options

El Cortez features multiple dining venues including Siegel's 1941, a 24-hour coffee shop, and The Parlour bar. The offerings are classic casino fare at very reasonable prices. Golden Gate is famous for its culinary offerings, particularly the original shrimp cocktail (served since 1959) and Du-Par's restaurant, known for excellent breakfast and pie. The property also features a more upscale bar experience.

Winner: Golden Gate (9/10 vs 7/10 for dining quality)

Casino Experience

El Cortez boasts a 40,000 square foot casino with over 1,000 slots, table games, and a race and sports book. The atmosphere is lively and retains old Vegas charm with lower minimum bets. Golden Gate's casino is more intimate at 25,000 square feet but features newer slot machines and popular table games. Both properties offer player rewards programs with good value.

Winner: El Cortez (8/10 vs 7/10 for casino variety and atmosphere)

Location and Accessibility

Both properties enjoy prime locations on Fremont Street in downtown Las Vegas. El Cortez sits at the eastern end of the Fremont Street Experience, offering slightly easier parking access. Golden Gate occupies the western end near the iconic Vegas Vic sign and container park. Both are within walking distance of all downtown attractions.

Winner: Tie (9/10 each for downtown location)

Value Proposition

El Cortez consistently offers some of the most affordable room rates in Las Vegas, often under $50 per night midweek. The property provides exceptional value for budget-conscious travelers. Golden Gate commands slightly higher rates ($80-150/night) but justifies the premium with better room quality and dining options.

Winner: El Cortez (10/10 vs 8/10 for pure budget value)

Service Quality

El Cortez provides friendly, no-frills service typical of older Vegas properties. Staff are experienced and efficient. Golden Gate offers more personalized service with a higher staff-to-guest ratio, reflecting its boutique hotel approach.

Winner: Golden Gate (8/10 vs 7/10 for service refinement)