Caesars Palace vs Treasure Island: A Comprehensive Showdown on the Las Vegas Strip

Accommodations & Room Quality

Caesars Palace features 3,960 rooms across multiple towers, with recent renovations in the Julius and Forum towers. Standard rooms start at 550 sq ft with marble bathrooms, Roman-inspired decor, and premium bedding. The Palace Tower offers the most luxurious standard accommodations.

Treasure Island offers 2,884 rooms with a more contemporary pirate-themed aesthetic. Rooms average 450 sq ft with comfortable bedding and modern amenities, though some show slight wear. The resort recently updated its tower suites.

Winner: Caesars Palace (Superior luxury and consistent quality)

Dining Options

Caesars Palace boasts an incredible 20+ dining venues including Gordon Ramsay Hell's Kitchen, Nobu, Restaurant Guy Savoy, and Pronto by Giada De Laurentiis. The Bacchanal Buffet is consistently ranked among Vegas's best.

Treasure Island offers more limited but quality options including The Coffee Bean, Gilley's Saloon, and Pho & Dim Sum. The highlight is Senor Frog's for casual Mexican and nightlife.

Winner: Caesars Palace (World-class culinary diversity)

Entertainment & Amenities

Caesars Palace features the Colosseum theater (home to major residencies), Garden of the Gods pool oasis with seven pools, Qua Baths & Spa (50,000 sq ft), and 300+ luxury shops in the Forum Shops.

Treasure Island offers the Mystère by Cirque du Soleil show, a more intimate pool scene, and a smaller but adequate spa. The casino floor is less overwhelming for casual gamers.

Winner: Caesars Palace (Superior entertainment and amenities)

Service & Hospitality

Caesars Palace provides polished, professional service though can feel impersonal during peak times. The concierge and front desk staff are well-trained but may experience delays during check-in/out rushes.

Treasure Island offers more personalized, friendly service with shorter wait times. The staff-to-guest ratio feels more attentive, though less formal than Caesars.

Winner: Treasure Island (More consistent personal service)

Location & Accessibility

Caesars Palace sits at the heart of the Strip with direct access to The Forum Shops and ideal proximity to Bellagio fountains, Mirage volcano, and other center-Strip attractions.

Treasure Island occupies a good north-Strip position near Fashion Show Mall and The Venetian, though requires more walking to reach center-Strip attractions. The free tram connects to The Mirage.

Winner: Caesars Palace (Prime center-Strip location)

Value & Pricing

Caesars Palace commands premium pricing with rooms averaging $250-500/night, plus resort fees around $45. Dining and amenities reflect luxury pricing throughout.

Treasure Island offers exceptional value with rooms typically $100-200/night and lower resort fees (~$35). Food and beverage prices are more reasonable throughout.

Winner: Treasure Island (Superior value proposition)

Overall Atmosphere

Caesars Palace delivers a grand, opulent Roman Empire theme with bustling energy, high-end clientele, and constant activity. The scale can feel overwhelming to some guests.

Treasure Island maintains a more relaxed, pirate-themed atmosphere with less crowded spaces and a more casual vibe. The resort feels more manageable and less intense.

Winner: Split Decision (Depends on preference for grandeur vs relaxation)